The nomination of Russian-Armenian businessman Ruben Vardanyan for the 2026 Václav Havel Human Rights Prize has triggered criticism.

The award is presented annually by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in recognition of contributions to human rights and civil society.

But analysts have argued that presenting Vardanyan as a human rights defender ignores allegations surrounding his political and financial activities in Garabagh and his reported links to Russian influence networks.

The nomination cites Vardanyan’s involvement in humanitarian initiatives and his so-called support for Armenians living in Garabagh.

But critics have argued that Vardanyan was not a neutral humanitarian figure, but rather a political actor who helped sustain separatism in Garabagh and obstruct dialogue efforts with Azerbaijan.

They have pointed to statements in which Vardanyan questioned coexistence between Azerbaijanis and Armenians, rhetoric they say contradicts the image of a peace advocate.

Ukranian expert criticises nomination 

Oleg Tuliakov, a Ukrainian expert at Sumy State University in Ukraine, said Vardanyan’s nomination for the prize was extremely worrying.

“The news of Ruben Vardanyan’s nomination for the Václav Havel Prize, a man convicted by an Azerbaijani court, including for terrorism, deeply concerns me.

“It’s not even about the nomination; it’s about doubts over the ability of the international humanitarian community to understand ethical criteria and establish ethical boundaries.”

Vardanyan moved to Garabagh in 2022 after renouncing his Russian citizenship and later became the so-called state minister of the former separatist administration.

His arrival fuelled speculation that Moscow was seeking to preserve its influence in the South Caucasus.

Vardanyan's conviction 

Azerbaijani authorities accused Vardanyan of financing illegal armed groups and violating the country’s laws. He was detained in September 2023 while attempting to leave for Armenia.

Vardanyan, 57, was later convicted on charges including financing terrorism, participating in illegal armed formations, war crimes and crimes against humanity.

Ukraine also sanctioned Vardanyan over alleged support for Russian aggression.

• From the Kremlin to Westminster: Exposing the Ruben Vardanyan lobby
• Ruben Vardanyan sentenced to 20 years in prison
• The rise and detention of the billionaire politician Ruben Vardanyan

In 2023, he was added to the Myrotvorets database, a Kyiv-based non-governmental list of individuals considered to be “enemies of Ukraine,” managed by activists.

Tuliakov said the Václav Havel Prize should return to the legacy of the Czech statesman after whom it is named.

“I am currently in Sumy, a border city that is shelled daily by Russian troops. People are being crippled, people are dying, our homes are being destroyed. This is happening, in part, because of the actions of people like Ruben Vardanyan,” Tuliakov said.

“I believe the time has come to return to the true legacy of Václav Havel, an outstanding politician and playwright, and in particular to his assertion of the ethical responsibility of politics,” he added.

Copied