Any U.S. military strike on Iran would almost certainly trigger cross-border retaliation and could ignite a wider regional war, according to political analyst James M. Dorsey.
Speaking to AnewZ, Dorsey said both Washington and Tehran are trying to avoid war, but that their public positions and political constraints are pushing them closer to confrontation. He said Washington and Tehran are effectively “boxed into a corner”, even as both signal a preference for negotiations rather than military action.
“I think it’s clear that both US President Trump and Iran would like to avoid a military confrontation. The problem is that they’ve both, in many ways, boxed themselves into a corner from which it’s going to be very difficult to escape with some sort of face-saving solution for both sides.”
However, he warned that the structural realities of any conflict would make escalation difficult to contain and that, because Tehran has few internal targets to hit, it would instead respond against US and allied positions across the Middle East.
“There are no Israeli or US targets inside Iran, so by definition Iranian retaliatory strikes would have to be cross-border, presumably in Israel and potentially US military facilities in the Gulf and maybe even Gulf infrastructure.”
While Washington has raised a broad list of demands, Dorsey said only the nuclear file offers realistic scope for compromise.
“The United States has several issues it wants to resolve ... nuclear, ballistic missiles, the crackdown on protesters, even though the protests for now have subsided and finally Iranian support for its non-state allies elsewhere in the Middle East.”
However, he stressed that Iran’s missile programme is not negotiable for any government in Tehran.
“There is a face-saving solution to be found, presumably on nuclear. But an issue like ballistic missiles is something that no Iranian government, whether Islamic revolutionary or post-revolutionary, would be able to accept. Ballistic missiles are core in the absence of any credible air force or navy.”
Against this backdrop, Iran has signalled readiness to explore diplomacy. Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian has ordered the start of nuclear talks with the United States, according to Iranian media, while sources in Tehran say negotiations involving senior officials from both countries could begin in the coming days.
The recent exchange of terrorist designations between Iran and the European Union, Dorsey said, is reinforcing confrontation rather than encouraging dialogue.
“It doesn’t really contribute. The problem here is that you’ve had belligerent language, both from the United States and from Iran and that belligerent language is mutually reinforcing rather than conducive to creating an environment in which a negotiated way out could be found.”
Dorsey said Iran’s recent protests stem largely from economic hardship, not foreign manipulation.
“There’s no doubt that there is widespread dissatisfaction in Iran, accelerated by the radical economic downturn that we’ve seen in recent months, the collapse of the Iranian currency, and mushrooming or spiralling inflation.”
“These protests were genuine, and Iran has a history - the Islamic Republic has a history since 1979 - of protests over various issues.”
He added that even if provocations occurred, they do not change the underlying nature of the unrest.
“That does not detract from the genuineness of these protests.”
Some regional states are quietly trying to lower tensions by urging a gradual approach.
“Türkiye is trying to do that alongside countries like Qatar. The Turkish foreign minister, in a recent interview, suggested to the Americans that rather than trying to resolve all issues at once, they take it issue by issue, starting with the nuclear problem.”
The scale of any conflict would depend heavily on the nature of Washington’s actions.
“Is it a one-time strike? Is it a sustained military campaign? What is the United States going to target?”
U.S. President Donald Trump has again said Iran is keen to reach a deal quickly, but a senior Iranian security official rejected the claim, saying ...
A drone hit a petrol station in Ukraine's capital of Kyiv early on Tuesday, Mayor Vitali Klitschko said on the...
Hundreds of thousands of deep-diving turtles, known as olive ridley sea turtles, have arrived on Mexico’s southern coast for one of nature&rs...
Maritime trackers received new reports of an attack on a ship in the Strait of Hormuz on Sunday, according to the UK Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO), adding to concerns about energy supplies after Saudi Arabia shut down a vital oil pipeline on Saturday.
A Kyiv-Warsaw train was struck near the Polish border, Ukraine's state railway firm said on Sunday. No passengers were injured. Ukrainian Railways said that the country's railways were facing systematic attacks for a second day and warned of widespread delays.
U.S. Central Command said 101 commercial vessels have been redirected in the Strait of Hormuz, while oil prices rose more than three per cent amid fresh regional attacks and supply concerns.
A Russian strike on a farm warehouse in Pryluky, north-central Ukraine, has killed at least three people, local police said. Meanwhile, EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said an attack on a train near the Polish border was an attempt to intimidate Ukraine's allies.
U.S. President Donald Trump has again said Iran is keen to reach a deal quickly, but a senior Iranian security official rejected the claim, saying Tehran will not negotiate until its conditions are met.
Syria says it has taken major steps to resolve long-running concerns over its nuclear programme, marking what officials describe as the beginning of a new phase of cooperation with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
Georgia has been formally integrated into the European Union's Trans-European Transport Network (TEN-T), bringing Anaklia Deep-Sea Port, Georgian Railway's main line and the East-West Highway into the network's expanded framework.
Türkiye’s foreign minister has renewed calls for the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) to disarm and disband, during talks with Syrian officials in Damascus.
Pakistan is providing targeted relief to millions of people after a sharp rise in global oil prices pushed domestic petrol and diesel prices higher, with disruption around two major Middle East shipping routes adding pressure to the country’s energy supply chain.
The European Union and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) have launched a $5.7 million initiative in Afghanistan to help farmers reach markets, strengthen agribusinesses and withstand climate and economic shocks.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment