A U.S. federal judge has rejected Meta Platforms’ attempt to dismiss a lawsuit brought by 29 state attorneys general, clearing the way for claims that the company designed Facebook and Instagram to be addictive to children and concealed risks from the public.
In a ruling issued in California, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers refused Meta’s request to throw out allegations of deceptive practices, unfair conduct and violations of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA).
The judge also ruled that Meta failed to comply with key provisions of the federal law, including requirements related to parental consent and notice, granting summary judgment to the states on that issue.
The lawsuit is part of a broader legal challenge by U.S. states that accuse Meta of knowingly creating features that encourage compulsive use among young people.
According to the attorneys general, research shows that excessive use of Facebook and Instagram can contribute to depression, anxiety, sleep disorders, educational difficulties and, in some cases, self-harm and suicide among children and teenagers.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta described the ruling as a significant step forward.
“This decision is a critical win in holding Meta accountable for fueling a mental health crisis among American children,” he said.
Meta said it strongly disagreed with the claims and remained confident it would prevail in court.
“We strongly disagree with these allegations and are confident the evidence will show our longstanding commitment to supporting young people,” the company said in a statement.
The technology giant argued that the states had failed to prove it misled users about the potential effects of its platforms. It also contended that “social media addiction” is not an officially recognised psychiatric condition, making statements denying addictiveness neither false nor misleading.
Meta further maintained that Facebook and Instagram are designed for a general audience rather than specifically targeting children under 13.
In her 38-page decision, Judge Gonzalez Rogers said key questions remain unresolved and should be considered by a jury.
These include whether Facebook and Instagram were intentionally designed to encourage compulsive use, whether Meta made misleading statements about the nature of its platforms, and whether the company partially targeted children despite its claims to the contrary.
“The AGs present a reasonable interpretation of (Meta's) statements that Facebook and Instagram are not designed in ways that cause teens to compulsively use the platforms to their detriment,” the judge wrote.
She added that if evidence shows the platforms were designed in such a way, “a jury could reasonably find the statements were untrue to a reasonable person”.
The case forms part of a broader wave of litigation against social media companies over their impact on young users.
Judge Gonzalez Rogers is also overseeing multidistrict litigation involving more than 2,600 individuals, school districts and local governments. The cases target several major technology firms, including Meta, Google, YouTube, Snapchat and TikTok, over allegations that their platforms contribute to addictive behaviour among children.
The next phase of the case is expected to begin soon. Court records show that a trial involving claims brought by California, Colorado, Kentucky and New Jersey is scheduled to start on 18 August.
The outcome could have significant implications for how social media companies design their platforms and address concerns about the well-being of younger users.
The lawsuit comes amid growing international scrutiny of Meta's platforms and their effect on children. In Europe, regulators are escalating an investigation into whether Facebook and Instagram use design features that keep young users hooked, with the European Commission examining claims that the platforms may be addictive to children.
The probe, launched under the EU's Digital Services Act, is also assessing whether Meta has done enough to protect minors online.
Elsewhere, Australia has introduced some of the world's toughest restrictions on children's social media use, with authorities investigating whether platforms including Facebook and Instagram are complying with rules aimed at keeping under-16s off social media.
Australian officials have repeatedly cited concerns about the impact of social media on young people's mental health and wellbeing.
The pressure on Meta extends beyond regulators. The company is already facing lawsuits in the United States alleging that its products contribute to addiction and mental health problems among young users, making the latest ruling part of a broader global debate over the responsibilities of social media companies towards children.
At least 132 people have died and 570 have been injured after a 7.4 magnitude earthquake struck western Colombia on Monday, the Colombian Association ...
Russia has welcomed what it describes as a shift in Georgia’s approach to the August 2008 war, praising statements that place responsibility for the...
U.S. President Donald Trump has called for Iran to pay compensation for decades of deaths and damage, adding a new demand to peace talks as Tehran see...
Flights arriving at Catania airport in eastern Sicily were suspended after volcanic ash from a new eruption of Mount Etna drifted into the airspace around the airport, disrupting operations at one of Italy’s busiest aviation hubs.
Greenland has issued a “strong warning” to a U.S. oil company linked to President Donald Trump after drilling equipment was brought ashore without the required government approvals, according to British media.
A deal on a new route for vessels through the Strait of Hormuz is "very close," Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has said, while warning that the reopening of the waterway depends on the U.S. meeting other conditions, including paying compensation to Iran.
Iran said it was nearing a final pact with Oman defining new shipping lanes between them through the Strait of Hormuz but repeated that the U.S. must meet other conditions.
Start your day informed with AnewZ Morning Brief. Here are the top news stories for the 9th of August, covering the latest developments.
At least 132 people have died and 570 have been injured after a 7.4 magnitude earthquake struck western Colombia on Monday, the Colombian Association of Capital Cities reported.
U.S. President Donald Trump has called for Iran to pay compensation for decades of deaths and damage, adding a new demand to peace talks as Tehran seeks compensation and sanctions relief before reopening the Strait of Hormuz.
Thousands of lawsuits accusing some of the world's biggest social media companies of designing platforms that keep young users hooked can now move forward after a U.S. appeals court rejected an attempt to halt the litigation.
A growing oil spill from a stranded tanker carrying nearly one million barrels of Russian crude has raised environmental concerns off the coast of Oman, where authorities are racing to contain a slick that now covers hundreds of square kilometres near a protected marine reserve.
U.S. President Donald Trump has signed an executive order calling for a reduction in the number of vaccines routinely recommended for children and endorsing changes to how some immunisations are administered, reigniting debate over U.S. vaccine policy and public health.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment