Donald Trump's attempt to end automatic citizenship for some children born in the U.S. has suffered a major setback after the Supreme Court declined to embrace the central constitutional argument behind his policy.
While the court recently sided with the Trump administration on the narrower issue of nationwide injunctions issued by lower courts, it stopped short of endorsing the president's attempt to reinterpret birthright citizenship.
The justices did not rule on whether the executive order itself is constitutional, leaving the issue unresolved and likely to be the subject of further litigation.
At the heart of the debate is the 14th Amendment, which has long been understood to confer U.S. citizenship on almost everyone born on American soil, regardless of their parents' immigration status. That interpretation has been reinforced by more than a century of legal precedent.
Trump's executive order sought to deny automatic citizenship to children born in the U.S. if their parents were in the country unlawfully or only temporarily. The move represented one of the most ambitious attempts in modern times to reshape U.S. immigration policy through executive action.
The proposal faced immediate legal challenges, with federal courts repeatedly concluding that it was likely to be unconstitutional. Judges across multiple jurisdictions blocked enforcement of the order, describing it as incompatible with the citizenship protections set out in the Constitution.
For Trump and his supporters, the policy formed part of a broader effort to tighten immigration controls and discourage illegal entry into the U.S. Critics argued that it represented a direct challenge to one of the country's most firmly established constitutional principles.
The outcome may push the administration to focus its efforts elsewhere in its immigration agenda. If barriers to entry are strengthened, officials argue, fewer undocumented migrants will be able to reach U.S. territory in the first place.
That strategy aligns with a broader emphasis on border enforcement, deportations, and tighter restrictions on asylum and immigration pathways. Rather than seeking to alter citizenship rules with deep constitutional roots, future policy initiatives may concentrate on preventing irregular migration before it reaches American soil.
The controversy surrounding birthright citizenship has become one of the most consequential legal and political debates in U.S. immigration policy. Supporters of the president's position argue that the 14th Amendment has been interpreted too broadly, while opponents maintain that any effort to narrow its protections would undermine a fundamental constitutional guarantee.
With the Supreme Court yet to issue a definitive ruling on the constitutionality of Trump's order, the issue is likely to remain before the courts and at the centre of political debate for years to come. What is clear, however, is that the justices were not prepared, at least for now, to overturn more than 150 years of legal understanding surrounding who becomes an American citizen at birth.
Demonstrators carrying Iranian flags and placards supporting the hijab gathered outside the Azerbaijani Embassy...
A Chinese-made AI chip has matched Nvidia’s H200 in tests conducted by its developer, marking a potential breakthrough in China’s effor...
China’s GJ-21 carrier-based stealth reconnaissance and strike drone has completed its first take-off and landing on board the Sichuan, the co...
The Middle East conflict remains tense as diplomatic efforts continue alongside renewed Houthi attacks. Iran says it remains open to mediation, while the Saudi-led coalition says it intercepted a ballistic missile fired towards the kingdom.
Rescuers searched the wreckage of two high-speed trains in central Spain on Thursday as the death toll rose to a provisional 74, making it the country's second fatal high-speed rail disaster this year.
Evacuations and the provision of humanitarian aid in the Russian-occupied southern Ukrainian town of Oleshky have begun, a senior Ukrainian official said on Friday. In a statement on Telegram, David Arakhamia said a six-day ceasefire was holding, and that more details would follow.
Qatari mediators returned to Tehran on Friday as part of efforts to reach a deal between the U.S. and Iran, according to an official briefed on the talks.
UN human rights experts comprising a group including Special Rapporteurs and independent experts who are part of the UN Human Rights Council, have criticised French authorities over their handling of nationwide student protests.
China’s GJ-21 carrier-based stealth reconnaissance and strike drone has completed its first take-off and landing on board the Sichuan, the country’s first Type 076 amphibious assault ship, state media reported on 30 October.
A powerful El Niño is driving extreme weather worldwide, leaving millions facing drought, wildfires and destructive storms as governments scramble to respond to the growing crisis.
A high-speed train involved in Wednesday's deadly collision in Spain was travelling at between 160 and 200 kilometres per hour, far above the 40 km/h safety limit, according to a preliminary investigation published on Friday.
Evacuations and the provision of humanitarian aid in the Russian-occupied southern Ukrainian town of Oleshky have begun, a senior Ukrainian official said on Friday. In a statement on Telegram, David Arakhamia said a six-day ceasefire was holding, and that more details would follow.
Hackers have pulled off a staggering $6.3 billion cryptocurrency heist targeting Binance, shaking confidence in one of the world's biggest digital asset exchanges and sending crypto prices tumbling. U.S. analysts suspect North Korea was behind the attack.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment