The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has ruled that Google’s refusal to allow Enel’s JuicePass app access to its Android Auto platform constitutes an abuse of its dominant market position, siding with Italy’s antitrust authority.
The decision, which is final and cannot be appealed, comes after the Italian watchdog fined Google 102 million euros in 2021 for blocking the e-mobility app - a tool designed to help drivers navigate and send messages safely while on the road.
Google had argued that its decision was based on security concerns and the absence of a clear template for refusing compatibility, contending that implementing interoperability would compromise the integrity of its platform. The company challenged the fine at the Italian Council of State, which subsequently sought guidance from the CJEU. Although Google has since enabled the requested feature, its stance during the dispute has raised broader questions about the responsibilities of dominant firms to ensure interoperability.
In its judgment, the CJEU noted, “A refusal by an undertaking in a dominant position to ensure that its platform is interoperable with an app of another undertaking, which thereby becomes more attractive, can be abusive.” However, the court also acknowledged that a company could justify its refusal if no standard template exists or if compatibility poses a security risk. In such cases, the dominant firm is expected to develop an appropriate template within a reasonable timeframe.
A Google spokesperson stated, “We prioritise building the features drivers need most because we believe that innovation should be driven by user demand, not specific companies' requests.” The spokesperson added that at the time of the request, the feature was relevant for only 0.04% of cars in Italy.
The ruling is expected to guide future actions by other dominant companies in similar situations. The Italian Council of State will now rule on Google’s appeal in line with the CJEU decision, as stakeholders across the technology and automotive sectors await further developments.
Read next
06:20
Security First
On May 19, London and Brussels are set to kick off their first annual summit, prioritizing a new UK–EU defense and security pact even as negotiations continue with Washington over tariff relief on British steel, cars and aerospace components.
14:56
Central Asia
Kyrgyzstan’s Prime Minister Adylbek Kasymaliev and EU Special Representative for Central Asia Eduards Stiprais discussed expanding energy projects and deepening bilateral and regional cooperation in the region.
16:59
Central Asia
Uzbekistan will host the next EU–Central Asia Economic and Investors’ Forums in November, EU Ambassador Toivo Klaar announced during Europe Day celebrations, highlighting growing ties and President Mirziyoyev’s planned visit to Brussels to sign a landmark agreement.
19:07
Sweden announced Tuesday it will propose that the European Union to join the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), aiming to create the world’s largest free trade area.
12:37
The European Commission is exploring alternative legal mechanisms to maintain pressure on Moscow if Hungary blocks the renewal of EU economic sanctions due to expire in July.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment