Menlo Park, CA, February 17, 2025 – Newly unsealed court documents from the case Kadrey v. Meta shed light on internal discussions among Meta employees about the use of copyrighted materials to train the company’s artificial intelligence models.
The filings, submitted by plaintiffs that include prominent authors, indicate that Meta staffers debated methods of incorporating copyrighted content—such as books and online data—obtained through legally questionable means, into training sets for models in the company’s Llama family.
According to the documents, internal work chats revealed that some Meta employees advocated an “ask forgiveness, not for permission” approach when considering the use of copyrighted works. In one discussion, research engineer Xavier Martinet suggested acquiring e-books at retail prices as an alternative to negotiating licensing deals with publishers. He noted that many startups were likely already using pirated content for similar purposes, arguing that direct licensing negotiations could be time-consuming.
Senior manager Melanie Kambadur and colleagues also discussed potential data sources, including Libgen—a website known for providing access to copyrighted works without authorization. One chat highlighted that some within the team viewed using Libgen as essential for achieving state-of-the-art model performance, despite its controversial legal status. To mitigate legal exposure, proposals were made to remove data marked as pirated and to refrain from publicly citing the use of such datasets.
The filings further reveal that Meta’s internal strategy included tuning AI models to “avoid IP risky prompts,” such as requests to reproduce extensive excerpts from copyrighted texts. Additional conversations touched on the possibility of revisiting previous decisions on training sets, with some team members arguing that Meta’s proprietary data from its social platforms was insufficient to meet the growing demands for training material.
Meta maintains that training its models on copyrighted works falls under “fair use,” a position that is contested by the plaintiffs in the case. The plaintiffs, which include well-known authors Sarah Silverman and Ta-Nehisi Coates, argue that Meta’s practices violate copyright law. In response, Meta has bolstered its legal team with Supreme Court litigators from the law firm Paul Weiss.
The case, pending in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, continues to raise complex questions about the balance between technological innovation, intellectual property rights, and the legal frameworks governing AI training data.
The European Commission has warned Meta that it may face daily fines starting 27 June if its modified pay-or-consent advertising model fails to meet EU antitrust requirements under the Digital Markets Act.
Meta has snapped up three star researchers from OpenAI's Zurich lab, escalating the fierce battle for top Artificial Intelligence talent as tech giants race to dominate the next era of artificial intelligence.
Meta has teamed up with Oakley to release AI-powered smart glasses, expanding its push into wearable tech after the success of Ray-Ban Meta glasses. The social media company is expanding its partnership with Oakley and Ray-Ban-parent EssilorLuxottica.
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has alleged that Meta Platforms offered signing bonuses as high as $100 million to OpenAI employees in an attempt to recruit top talent, underscoring the intensifying competition among tech firms for artificial intelligence expertise.
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg has launched a 'superintelligence' project to take artificial intelligence to a new level. According to Bloomberg, Zuckerberg is assembling an exclusive team of leading AI experts to create technology that surpasses human-level capabilities.
Ukraine's Security Service carried out overnight airstrikes on a Russian military airfield in occupied Crimea, reportedly destroying three helicopters and a key air defense system.
A former Venezuelan military intelligence official has pleaded guilty in the United States to drug trafficking and narco-terrorism charges, concluding a two-year legal process following his extradition.
Azerbaijan has summoned Russia’s envoy in Baku to protest the deadly raids targeting Azerbaijani nationals in Yekaterinburg, demanding a full investigation and accountability.
Iran has barred the UN nuclear watchdog’s chief from entering the country and suspended camera installations at its nuclear facilities, escalating tensions over transparency following recent military clashes.
Iran launched 18 ballistic missiles late Sunday targeting the U.S. military’s Al-Udeid Air Base in Qatar, the largest American installation in the Middle East.
The U.S. economy faces a 40% risk of recession in the second half of 2025, JP Morgan analysts said on Wednesday, citing rising tariffs and stagflation concerns.
Severe rain in Venezuela has caused rivers to overflow and triggered landslides, sweeping away homes and collapsing a highway bridge, with five states affected and no casualties reported so far.
The U.S. Embassy in Qatar has advised American citizens to shelter in place amid rising tensions between Israel and Iran, as part of a broader global security alert issued by Washington.
China has ramped up efforts to protect communities impacted by flood control measures, introducing stronger compensation policies and direct aid from the central government.
Chile's Vera C. Rubin Observatory has unveiled its first cosmic images, captured using the world's largest digital camera, paving the way for breakthroughs in understanding the solar system and monitoring asteroid threats to Earth.
Germany’s data protection commissioner has called on Apple and Google to block the Chinese AI app DeepSeek from their platforms over illegal data transfers and privacy concerns.
Australian scientists have developed synthetic chemicals to attract crown-of-thorns starfish for mass removal, offering a safer, targeted method to protect coral reefs.
SoftBank CEO Masayoshi Son said on Friday the group aims to become the world’s top platform provider for artificial super intelligence within the next decade, signaling a bold new direction for the Japanese tech giant.
A belt of volcanic rock in northeastern Quebec has been dated to 4.16 billion years ago, making it the oldest known rock on Earth and offering rare insight into the planet’s mysterious infancy.
Ukraine's Security Service carried out overnight airstrikes on a Russian military airfield in occupied Crimea, reportedly destroying three helicopters and a key air defense system.
A former Venezuelan military intelligence official has pleaded guilty in the United States to drug trafficking and narco-terrorism charges, concluding a two-year legal process following his extradition.
Azerbaijan has summoned Russia’s envoy in Baku to protest the deadly raids targeting Azerbaijani nationals in Yekaterinburg, demanding a full investigation and accountability.
Iran has barred the UN nuclear watchdog’s chief from entering the country and suspended camera installations at its nuclear facilities, escalating tensions over transparency following recent military clashes.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment