A federal judge has dismissed a high-profile lawsuit brought by the Trump administration that sought to pre-emptively stop the state of Hawaii from suing major fossil fuel companies over the local impacts of climate change.
In a ruling on Wednesday, the court cited a “longstanding” precedent against unwarranted federal intervention in state court processes, dealing a setback to Washington’s strategy of shielding the oil and gas industry from state-level legal action.
The decision by U.S. District Judge Helen Gillmor in Honolulu marks the second time in early 2026 that federal courts have blocked the U.S. Department of Justice’s (DOJ) attempts to halt environmental lawsuits before they are heard in state courts. The ruling reinforces a pattern of judicial resistance to the administration’s approach.
Earlier this year, in January, another federal judge dismissed a similar DOJ lawsuit aimed at preventing Michigan from pursuing action against major oil companies under environmental and consumer protection laws.
Neither the Justice Department nor Hawaii’s Attorney General’s office immediately responded to requests for comment.
The legal dispute dates back to April 2025, when the Justice Department filed simultaneous lawsuits against Hawaii and Michigan in an unprecedented move. The DOJ sought federal injunctions to block both states from launching planned multi-billion-dollar lawsuits against global oil companies.
The Trump administration argued that allowing individual states to regulate greenhouse gas emissions through litigation would create a fragmented regulatory landscape. It also claimed such cases posed a threat to national security, warning they could harm domestic energy production, increase fuel prices and undermine its goal of energy dominance.
However, the strategy failed to deter state action. One day after the federal filing in 2025, Hawaii proceeded with its own lawsuit in state court against a group of major fossil fuel firms, including BP Plc, Chevron Corp, Exxon Mobil Corp and Shell Plc.
The case alleges the companies carried out a decades-long campaign of deception, selling products they knew would contribute to global warming while funding disinformation to obscure climate science. Hawaii is seeking damages to cover rising costs linked to sea-level rise, coastal erosion and extreme weather.
In dismissing the case, Judge Gillmor did not address climate science or the oil companies’ conduct. Instead, she focused on constitutional limits to federal jurisdiction.
She ruled that the DOJ lacked legal standing because its claims were too speculative. To bring a case in federal court, a plaintiff must demonstrate a “concrete and particularised” injury.
The Justice Department argued that a potential future victory for Hawaii could harm federal energy interests. Judge Gillmor rejected this argument.
“The Justice Department’s ‘attempt to predict the outcome of a yet-to-be-filed lawsuit and how it could possibly injure the federal government in the future is not a concrete injury-in-fact',” Gillmor wrote.
She also stressed the importance of federalism, noting that federal courts should not interfere lightly with a state’s right to use its own legal system to seek redress.
With the federal case dismissed, Hawaii’s lawsuit against BP, Chevron, ExxonMobil and Shell will now move to the discovery phase in state court. This stage could compel the companies to disclose internal communications about their knowledge of climate science.
Legal experts say the ruling may encourage other U.S. states and cities to pursue similar claims, potentially leading to prolonged and costly litigation for the fossil fuel industry over its role in climate change.
Iran said on Sunday (10 May) that it had sent its response to a U.S. proposal aimed at launching peace talks to end the war, as signs of tentative ...
Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico has cited Azerbaijan as an example of what he described as a sovereign foreign policy, recalling rem...
China’s exports grew faster than expected in April, as overseas buyers moved quickly to secure supplies a...
President Donald Trump called Iran’s response to a US war proposal “totally unacceptable” after Tehran sent its reply through med...
Russia is holding a significantly scaled-back Victory Day parade in Moscow on 9 May 2026, reflecting heightened security concerns and the ongoing w...
Iran said on Sunday (10 May) that it had sent its response to a U.S. proposal aimed at launching peace talks to end the war, as signs of tentative movement emerged around the Strait of Hormuz despite renewed security incidents across the Gulf.
Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico has cited Azerbaijan as an example of what he described as a sovereign foreign policy, recalling remarks made by President Ilham Aliyev during talks in Yerevan, where he sharply criticised resolutions adopted against his country by the European Parliament.
Russia is holding a significantly scaled-back Victory Day parade in Moscow on 9 May 2026, reflecting heightened security concerns and the ongoing war in Ukraine, now in its fourth year.
Centre-right leader Péter Magyar was sworn in as Hungary’s prime minister on Saturday, propelled into office on promises of change after years of economic stagnation and strained ties with key allies under his predecessor Viktor Orbán.
Efforts to end the U.S.-Iran war appeared to stall as the two sides exchanged fire in and around the Strait of Hormuz. A reported CIA assessment suggested Tehran could withstand a U.S. naval blockade for months despite mounting sanctions and renewed Gulf attacks.
British paratroopers and military medics have been deployed to Tristan da Cunha after a suspected hantavirus case was confirmed, as first evacuation flights carrying passengers from the stricken MV Hondius cruise ship left Tenerife for Madrid and Paris.
Russia is holding a significantly scaled-back Victory Day parade in Moscow on 9 May 2026, reflecting heightened security concerns and the ongoing war in Ukraine, now in its fourth year.
Indonesian rescue teams have located two Singaporeans who went missing after Mount Dukono erupted on Friday (8 May) on the island of Halmahera, though authorities say it remains unclear whether they are alive.
The U.S. Defense Department has released dozens of previously classified files on unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAP) on Friday (8 May), following an order from President Donald Trump. U.S. officials described as a push for “unprecedented transparency”.
China’s leading chipmakers are funnelling unprecedented sums into research and development as Beijing accelerates efforts to reduce reliance on foreign technology amid intensifying U.S. export restrictions.
Centre-right leader Péter Magyar was sworn in as Hungary’s prime minister on Saturday, propelled into office on promises of change after years of economic stagnation and strained ties with key allies under his predecessor Viktor Orbán.
The United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) has warned that France risks undermining the self-determination rights of the Kanak Indigenous People in New Caledonia amid proposed political and constitutional reforms.
Somalia is facing a severe malnutrition crisis and urgently needs additional humanitarian funding to prevent conditions deteriorating further, the World Food Programme has warned.
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer vowed to carry on as leader on Friday (8 May) after his ruling Labour Party suffered heavy losses in local elections. Labour lost hundreds of councillors across the country, as some figures in the party said he should stand down.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment