OpenAI is challenging a court order that requires it to indefinitely preserve ChatGPT output data in an ongoing copyright lawsuit filed by The New York Times, arguing that the mandate risks violating user privacy.
In a court filing submitted on June 3, OpenAI asked U.S. District Judge Sidney Stein to vacate the data preservation order issued in May. The company contends that maintaining all user output logs indefinitely conflicts with its stated privacy commitments.
"We will fight any demand that compromises our users' privacy; this is a core principle," OpenAI CEO Sam Altman wrote in a post on X (formerly Twitter) on Thursday. “We think this [The Times’ demand] was an inappropriate request that sets a bad precedent.”
The dispute stems from a lawsuit filed in 2023 by The New York Times against both OpenAI and Microsoft, alleging that the companies used millions of the newspaper’s articles without authorization to train generative AI models. The suit is seen as one of the most significant legal tests to date of how copyright law applies to artificial intelligence training data.
While The New York Times declined to comment on the appeal, earlier court filings showed the newspaper had requested preservation of all relevant ChatGPT outputs to support its claims.
Judge Stein previously allowed the case to proceed, stating in an April opinion that the Times had made a plausible case that OpenAI and Microsoft may have “induced” users to infringe on its copyrights. He cited the Times' documentation of "numerous" and "widely publicized" instances where ChatGPT reproduced its content.
The outcome of the appeal could influence how courts balance user privacy with evidentiary demands in copyright litigation involving AI-generated content — a legal frontier with growing implications for both tech companies and media organizations.
Read next
17:13
U.S. strikes on Iran
Azerbaijan’s Foreign Ministry on Saturday voiced deep concern over the escalating tensions following the United States’ military strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, calling on all sides to prioritize diplomacy over confrontation.
16:11
Bold and Brilliant
The Pentagon concluded a high-stakes press briefing Saturday afternoon following the U.S. strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities, outlining the scale and success of the mission while stressing the door remains open to diplomacy.
15:53
Türkiye
Türkiye has voiced strong concern following the United States’ strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, warning that the action could dangerously escalate the conflict and trigger a global crisis.
14:00
oil price
Global investors are bracing for significant market turmoil when trading reopens, with analysts predicting a sharp spike in oil prices and a flight to safe-haven assets following the United States' announcement of military strikes against three Iranian nuclear facilities.
13:55
"Red Line" crossed
Iran’s top diplomat on Sunday issued a stark condemnation of the United States following overnight military strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, declaring that Washington had crossed a "very big red line" and would be held "fully responsible" for the consequences.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment