Five major carmakers have largely won the first stage of a major legal battle at a High Court case brought by around 1.6 million claimants in the UK over allegations that their diesel vehicles were fitted with unlawful "defeat devices" that led to higher emissions.
The court rejected most of the claims against Mercedes, Ford, Peugeot-Citroën, Renault and Nissan, ruling that the emissions-control strategies used in most of the vehicles examined did not amount to illegal "defeat devices" under UK regulations.
The case centred on 20 sample vehicles, with claimants arguing the manufacturers used software to reduce emissions during official tests while allowing higher emissions in normal driving. The court found that a prohibited defeat device requires an intention to make the emissions-control system behave differently during testing, and that not all calibration strategies breach the rules.
Lawyers representing the claimants said they were considering a possible appeal against Friday's ruling, which they said "adopted a significantly narrower interpretation of the law than that applied elsewhere in Europe".
However, the judgment identified some exceptions. The court found that a device used in certain Mercedes vehicles, later removed through a software update in 2015, breached the regulations. It also ruled against a "split-injection" emissions strategy used in some Peugeot-Citroën Euro 5 diesel models.
A Mercedes-Benz spokesperson welcomed the ruling, saying the court had found "very largely in favour" of the company. However, the automaker said it disagreed with the finding against it and was considering its options, including a possible appeal.
Stellantis-owned brands Peugeot and Citroen said only one allegation was upheld against it and it was considering the possibility of seeking leave to appeal.
"Stellantis maintains its firm position that all its vehicles comply with applicable emissions regulations," the manufacturer said in a statement.
A further trial is scheduled for October to determine the legal consequences of those findings and assess any potential damages.
The case is the largest group litigation in the history of England and Wales and follows the wider Volkswagen Dieselgate scandal, in which the German carmaker admitted cheating emissions tests and later settled claims brought by UK motorists.
Around 11,000 people joined a demonstration in Orléans on Saturday against the National Rally congress, according to the local prefecture....
Israeli forces have maintained a tight closure on Hebron in the occupied West Bank for a second day, with Palestinian media reporting home raids, m...
German police have detained a suspect after a major fire broke out at the historic Kehlsteinhaus, known as the “Eagle’s Nest&rdqu...
Israeli military bulldozers have begun demolishing buildings in the West Bank city of Hebron on Friday, 23 October, following armed clashes with Palestinians that left two Israeli soldiers dead, according to the Israeli military.
Saudi Aramco has ordered staff to evacuate its headquarters amid escalating Houthi attacks on the kingdom. Two people were killed in an attack on Dammam airport, while Iran's IRGC Navy claimed strikes on seven vessels and warned the U.S. of a wider response.
Russian strikes on Ukraine overnight killed at least two people and injured 15 others, including two children, Ukrainian authorities said. Meanwhile, Russia said it had intercepted the vast majority of 630 Ukrainian drones launched towards Moscow.
A powerful magnitude 7 earthquake has struck Tibet in southwestern China, killing 16 people and injuring 65, while forcing more than 12,000 residents to relocate as rescue teams respond to widespread aftershocks.
Missile and drone attacks have put Saudi Arabia on high alert, disrupting life in Riyadh and testing a new defence pact with Türkiye and Pakistan as regional tensions escalate.
Around 11,000 people joined a demonstration in Orléans on Saturday against the National Rally congress, according to the local prefecture.
German police have detained a suspect after a major fire broke out at the historic Kehlsteinhaus, known as the “Eagle’s Nest”, a mountain retreat once used by senior Nazi officials, including Adolf Hitler.
Typhoon Champi swept past Taiwan on Saturday, leaving one person dead and more than 500 injured as strong winds and torrential rain brought down trees, cut power and disrupted transport across the island.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on Friday dismissed accusations that Canada planned to interfere in next month’s U.S. midterm elections, saying he was disappointed by comments from the American ambassador.
Kenya has recorded a second death from Ebola, the health ministry said late on Friday, as the outbreak that began in the Democratic Republic of Congo continues to spread across Africa.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment