Opinion: Syrian authorities rebuild new police force

Syria’s interim government is making efforts to rebuild a weakened and disbanded police force following the collapse of the Assad regime on December 8, 2024.

The new leadership is placing Islamic principles at the core of its policing framework, aiming to instill ethical governance and eradicate the corruption and abuses that characterised the previous regime. However, this shift has raised concerns about the government’s earlier pledge to establish an inclusive political system free from sectarian and ideological dominance.

The interim government, led by Ahmed al-Sharaa, has sought to reassure both Western and regional stakeholders about its intentions. Al-Sharaa has emphasised that his faction has renounced past ties to al-Qaeda and is committed to moderation and the protection of minorities. However, critics argue that the inclusion of religious criteria in police recruitment could alienate large segments of Syrian society and undermine inclusivity in the post-Assad era.

Recruitment and Religious Criteria

The new police force is drawing recruits primarily from Idlib, a province that served as a stronghold for the Islamist opposition during the civil war. Candidates are being vetted based on both their skills and personal religious beliefs, a move the government justifies as essential for ensuring ethical conduct within the force.

However, this approach has sparked controversy, with many Syrians fearing the creation of a police force rooted in ideological bias rather than professionalism and neutrality. The government argues that these reforms are designed to establish clear guidelines for appropriate conduct, ensuring the new force does not replicate the brutality of the Assad-era police.

Skeptics, however, point to the dominance of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) within the interim government. While HTS has attempted to portray itself as a pragmatic entity, moderating its enforcement of Islamic law in areas under its control, many Syrians remain apprehensive about its long-term influence over the country's governance.

Public and International Concerns

The increasing role of Islamic principles in the police force has divided public opinion. While some Sunni Muslim communities support the initiative, others—including Christians, Alawites, and even segments of the Sunni majority—fear that the move could usher in a theocratic system rather than a broad-based government.

Western diplomats have also raised concerns, questioning the extent to which Islamic principles will shape governance and law enforcement in post-Assad Syria. While acknowledging the need for moral reform in public institutions, they worry that the approach could lead to systemic exclusion or further repression of minorities.

A Balancing Act for the Interim Government

The interim government faces a delicate challenge: balancing the need for moral and institutional reform with the promise of inclusivity and fairness. While the emphasis on Islamic principles may resonate with some factions, it risks alienating others. Moving forward, the leadership must demonstrate transparency and a commitment to impartial governance to gain broader support, both domestically and internationally.

As Syria embarks on its post-Assad rebuilding process, the composition and conduct of its new police force will serve as a litmus test for the nation’s future. Whether it becomes a symbol of justice or a tool of ideological control remains to be seen.

Copied