As cardinals prepare to choose the next leader of the Catholic Church, tensions are rising over whether Rome should continue to hold central authority in a rapidly globalizing faith.
As the May 7 conclave approaches, cardinals gather daily in Vatican City under the leadership of a 91-year-old cardinal to pay homage to the late Pope Francis — and quietly plot the direction of the Catholic Church’s future. Behind the formalities of respectful tributes lies an intense struggle over the very locus of power in a Church of 1.4 billion followers.
At the heart of this contest is a fundamental question: Should the Roman Curia continue to dominate global Catholic governance, or should authority shift outward to reflect the Church's growing geographic and cultural diversity?
Tensions Behind the Politeness
Inside the general congregations — the formal, pre-conclave meetings — cardinals carefully veil their critiques of Francis’ papacy.
“Everyone’s speaking well of Pope Francis,” one source noted. “But the way they speak good about him shows they don’t like him.”
Despite this diplomatic tone, divisions run deep. While doctrinal debates remain a factor, a more structural power struggle is unfolding over where — and by whom — decisions about theology and governance should be made.
Francis' Disruption of Old Power Structures
Francis, who died on April 21, spent his papacy decentralizing Church power, promoting non-European cardinals, and empowering laypeople and clerics from Africa, Asia, and Latin America. He created 50 new voting-age cardinals from often-overlooked locales such as Bridgetown (St. Lucia) and Bogor (Indonesia), while bypassing traditional dioceses like Los Angeles and San Francisco.
His synodal process — extended for another three years just before his death — pushed the Church toward broader consultation and inclusion. But critics say it also fragmented the implementation of doctrine and diminished the influence of the Vatican bureaucracy.
Enter Pietro Parolin: The Rome-Focused Candidate
At the center of current lobbying is Cardinal Pietro Parolin, the Vatican’s Secretary of State and a longtime ally of Francis. Though once seen as a neutral diplomat, Parolin has become a rallying point for those who seek to restore the Vatican’s central authority.
Parolin’s quiet leadership during Francis' final illness, and his prominent prayer appearance in February, sparked both admiration and suspicion. Some see him as a continuation of Francis’ internationalism, while others portray him as a stabilizing force against what they view as disruptive decentralization.
Despite past controversies — including a scandal involving Vatican financial dealings and contentious diplomacy with China — Parolin enjoys backing from senior curial officials, especially Italians who are eager to see one of their own become pope for the first time in nearly five decades.
Divided Opposition and Weak Alternatives
Those in the pro-synodal camp are wary. They argue that Parolin might roll back some of Francis’ reforms and have instead floated Cardinal Mario Grech, general secretary of the synod, as a continuity candidate. Yet their camp is fractured and lacks a unifying figure.
“Rome cannot understand all the dynamics going on in different continents,” said one source, warning against re-centralization. “They don’t want the Church directed by the Roman Curia.”
Church historian Miles Pattenden notes that newer cardinals from far-flung dioceses may struggle to resist seasoned power brokers in Rome, particularly those from Europe and North America.
The Uncertain Road Ahead
Though Parolin’s name has gained traction, the Vatican's papal elections are notorious for sidelining frontrunners. Criticism of his recent Mass performance — seen as lacking charisma — has raised doubts about his “popeability.”
Ultimately, the push for Parolin may be more symbolic than personal — a signal that, for many cardinals, Rome’s primacy remains essential to the Church’s identity.
In an institution steeped in tradition, the idea of a decentralized Church may prove as unthinkable to some as the idea of a papacy without Rome at its center.
President Donald Trump says he still wants to annex Greenland and possibly Canada, but while he won’t rule out the use of force, he claims an attack on Canada is “highly unlikely.”
President Donald Trump is touting strong job numbers as proof of his economic leadership while blaming former President Joe Biden for lingering problems, even as economic indicators show mixed signals.
NATO's top transformation commander has issued a stark warning: Europe risks being left behind in the increasingly militarized space race, outpaced by private players like Elon Musk and strategic rivals such as China and Russia.
The OPEC+ alliance announced on Saturday it will increase oil production by 411,000 barrels per day (bpd) in June, marking the second consecutive month of accelerated output hikes despite falling prices and dimming demand forecasts.
A tragic vehicle crash at Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) in Manila on Sunday morning has left two people dead, including a young girl, and injured three others, according to officials.
Authorities say they stopped a planned attack on Lady Gaga’s Copacabana concert, which drew over 2 million fans.
A missile strike on Ben Gurion Airport wounded eight and disrupted flights, as Yemen’s Houthis warn airlines the site is no longer safe.
President Donald Trump says he still wants to annex Greenland and possibly Canada, but while he won’t rule out the use of force, he claims an attack on Canada is “highly unlikely.”
President Donald Trump is touting strong job numbers as proof of his economic leadership while blaming former President Joe Biden for lingering problems, even as economic indicators show mixed signals.
As cardinals prepare to choose the next leader of the Catholic Church, tensions are rising over whether Rome should continue to hold central authority in a rapidly globalizing faith.
Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov has announced the upcoming release of a documentary film about Russian President Vladimir Putin.
New Tesla registrations in Denmark collapsed 67 % in April to 180 vehicles, industry data showed Thursday, underscoring a sharp demand drop for the EV maker in one of its once-strong European markets.
Roman Catholic cardinals will meet in a secret conclave to elect the new leader of the global Church starting from May 7, a senior Vatican source said on Monday.
As President Donald Trump reaches the end of his first 100 days in his second term, his presidency has been marked by significant executive actions, controversial immigration policies, economic volatility, and a major reorganization of the federal government.
Discover every major VE Day 80 event in Britain, 5‑8 May 2025—from London’s parade and fly‑past to street parties, concerts and museum exhibitions.
Authorities say they stopped a planned attack on Lady Gaga’s Copacabana concert, which drew over 2 million fans.
A missile strike on Ben Gurion Airport wounded eight and disrupted flights, as Yemen’s Houthis warn airlines the site is no longer safe.
President Donald Trump says he still wants to annex Greenland and possibly Canada, but while he won’t rule out the use of force, he claims an attack on Canada is “highly unlikely.”
President Donald Trump is touting strong job numbers as proof of his economic leadership while blaming former President Joe Biden for lingering problems, even as economic indicators show mixed signals.
NATO's top transformation commander has issued a stark warning: Europe risks being left behind in the increasingly militarized space race, outpaced by private players like Elon Musk and strategic rivals such as China and Russia.
Authorities say they stopped a planned attack on Lady Gaga’s Copacabana concert, which drew over 2 million fans.
A missile strike on Ben Gurion Airport wounded eight and disrupted flights, as Yemen’s Houthis warn airlines the site is no longer safe.
President Donald Trump says he still wants to annex Greenland and possibly Canada, but while he won’t rule out the use of force, he claims an attack on Canada is “highly unlikely.”
President Donald Trump is touting strong job numbers as proof of his economic leadership while blaming former President Joe Biden for lingering problems, even as economic indicators show mixed signals.
As cardinals prepare to choose the next leader of the Catholic Church, tensions are rising over whether Rome should continue to hold central authority in a rapidly globalizing faith.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment