A CIA review has identified procedural flaws in a 2016 assessment that Russia sought to help Donald Trump win the U.S. presidency, but it did not challenge the core conclusion that President Vladimir Putin directed the influence campaign.
The review, released on Wednesday, found that while the intelligence assessment suffered from “multiple procedural anomalies,” its core findings remained credible. It questioned the use of a “high confidence” rating by the CIA and FBI, suggesting a “moderate confidence” level—used by the National Security Agency—would have been more appropriate.
The December 2016 classified assessment concluded that Putin ordered a disinformation and cyber campaign aimed at swaying the U.S. election in Trump’s favour. That judgment has since been supported by a bipartisan Senate Intelligence Committee report released in 2018.
However, the CIA’s Directorate of Analysis, which conducted the internal review, cited issues including a compressed timeline and “excessive involvement of agency heads” that led to deviations from standard analytic procedures. These factors, it said, undermined the application of rigorous tradecraft in forming the most contested conclusions.
The review was commissioned by former Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe, a Trump appointee, during his tenure as CIA director. According to a CIA statement, the aim was to “promote analytic objectivity and transparency.”
Trump has consistently rejected the intelligence community’s findings about Russian interference, frequently citing Putin’s denials. After meeting the Russian leader in 2017, he said he believed Putin’s assurances over the U.S. agencies’ conclusions.
The review did not challenge the existence or scope of the Russian influence effort, reaffirming that the CIA report used by analysts remained “quality and credible.” Nonetheless, the re-evaluation highlights longstanding concerns within the intelligence community about politicisation and methodological rigour in high-stakes assessments.
Russia has not yet confirmed a report by U.S. President Donald Trump that Moscow has reached an immediate “energy ceasefire”&nbs...
One person was killed and nearly a dozen hurt in a new attack Riyadh's international airport on Sunday, Saudi ...
India’s ‘Cockroach’ movement began as an online satire-driven initiative and evolved into a p...
The explosion at King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh on Saturday afternoon killed at least 12 people and injured a further 309, according to Saudi Arabia’s Civil Aviation Authority. The airport remains closed until further notice.
Yemen's Houthis renewed warning to airlines, airport workers, and travellers against using Saudi airports, saying the warning should be taken seriously and that the kingdom “bore responsibility for failed interceptions”, a day after an attack on Riyadh's international airport that killed 12 people.
Ukraine is ready to stop attacks on Russian oil refineries if Moscow also halts strikes on Ukrainian energy infrastructure, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on Sunday.
Russian President Vladimir Putin expressed surprise after Donald Trump mediated the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace agreement in 2025, the U.S. President said at a rally in New York state on Friday.
The United Nations has condemned a sharp rise in attacks on civilians in Ukraine, reporting that more than 100 people were killed and at least 429 injured in a single week as Russian strikes hit residential areas, passenger buses and critical infrastructure.
Russia has not yet confirmed a report by U.S. President Donald Trump that Moscow has reached an immediate “energy ceasefire” with Ukraine. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says Kyiv is still waiting for details and for Moscow to confirm it will support the deal.
India’s ‘Cockroach’ movement began as an online satire-driven initiative and evolved into a protest group challenging political and institutional decisions. It has since drawn attention over education-related grievances and is now calling for the resignation of India’s Chief Election Commissioner.
The Pentagon’s plan to livestream the execution of Nidal Hasan, the former U.S. Army psychiatrist who killed 13 people and wounded more than 30 others at Fort Hood in 2009, has raised questions about the legality of broadcasting executions and the limits of military justice.
Within a week of the death of Darya Shipilova, a 28-year-old worker at a Siberian plague institute, a neighbouring governor raised the possibility of plague, regulators found no evidence of it and Irkutsk lifted its quarantine. What killed her remains unexplained.
Polish police have detained a man suspected of planning an attack on Prime Minister Donald Tusk and Defence Minister Wladyslaw Kosiniak-Kamysz, prompting security services to convene a special meeting on Sunday.
You can download the AnewZ application from Play Store and the App Store.
What is your opinion on this topic?
Leave the first comment