Pope Leo XIV’s election prompts mixed response from US conservatives

Reuters

The election of Pope Leo XIV, the first American pontiff, has drawn a range of responses in the United States, with some conservative figures expressing concern over his past remarks on immigration and politics.

The election of Pope Leo XIV — the first American to lead the Roman Catholic Church — has prompted varied reactions in the United States, particularly among conservative political figures aligned with former President Donald Trump.

Pope Leo XIV, born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago, is known for his previous roles within the Church and his association with Pope Francis. While President Trump described Leo’s election as a “great honour” for the United States, some of his supporters have questioned the Pope’s past comments on issues such as immigration and social policy.

Former White House strategist Steve Bannon told the BBC that he found some of Pope Leo’s past remarks on social media surprising, particularly those perceived as critical of US immigration policies. He suggested that differences in perspective between the Pope and political leaders could lead to tension.

Other figures associated with the conservative media landscape expressed similar views. Some referenced social media posts attributed to the new Pope, which included support for immigrants and discussions around Church social teachings. The Vatican has not officially confirmed the authenticity of the account in question.

Pope Leo’s brother, John Prevost, said in media interviews that the new pontiff has strong opinions on immigration and may choose to express them during his papacy. However, it remains unclear how these views may influence his leadership of the global Church.

Polling data from Pew Research Center indicates that around 20% of Americans identify as Catholic, with views on political and social issues varying widely across the community. While a majority of US Catholics have historically viewed Pope Francis favourably, opinions within conservative circles have been more divided.

The US Conference of Catholic Bishops welcomed Pope Leo XIV’s election, highlighting his message of peace, unity, and missionary focus as signs of continuity in Church leadership.

Public reactions among Catholics in Chicago, where Pope Leo grew up, were largely positive. Some expressed hopes that he would carry forward Pope Francis’s emphasis on social justice and inclusivity.

Although some conservative commentators have voiced reservations, others, including Vice-President JD Vance, offered a more measured response. Vance said he expected to both agree and disagree with the new Pope at times but affirmed his ongoing support for the Church.

Pope Leo XIV’s views on a number of key issues, including immigration, economic policy, and Church governance, are expected to become clearer as his papacy unfolds.

Tags

Comments (0)

What is your opinion on this topic?

Leave the first comment